Home page
SPONSOR AD

Support our Vendors!  |  Advertise Here

Topic: 95 running rough with some pinging

in Forum: C4 Engines


Already a Member?
Login
Not yet a Member?
Register for Free!

95 running rough with some pinging (1/23)
 7/9/13 12:36pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

My stock 95 typically runs great. Yesterday after work, I started it up and it started running rough. Quite rough at idle, but also running a little rough while driving, as well. It does smooth out some while driving, but I can still tell that it's rough compared to its usual very smooth running. It is also pinging a bit under load. This is all not typical at all. It never pings and typically runs so smoothly. It does still start up right away without any issue. 

The other thing, and I don't know if they're related, is that the other day, it seemed to get "stuck" at a somewhat higher idle, around 1100. Turned off the engine and restarted, and it idled normal again. Apparently, this also happened once before, a few days earlier, when my husband was driving it.

No engine light on. I think that would mean no codes, but I could be wrong. 

A visual inspection showed nothing loose or no broken looking lines.  Also, checked TPS voltage from idle position to WOT, and was in specs, rose normally as expected from .58 up to 4.01.

Any ideas/suggestions would be appreciated. Thanks.


______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Our Sponsors help support C4VR
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (2/23)
 7/9/13 12:50pm
epohdivad
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Kearns, UT - USA

Vette(s):
1990, L98, 6 Speed Manual, Brilliant red metallic


Joined: 4/6/2012
Posts: 86

Hmmm how old is the old fuel filter?  I know you have a different engine block but always good to check spark plug wires and the cap.  On the L98 the distributor sits just barely under the firewall and if the wires aren't just right - rubs off the insulation and sparks start free jumping...  but I know, you don't have the L98.  Also good to check the air filter.  Just some thoughts.

______________

Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (3/23)
 7/9/13 1:48pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

Thank you.  I'm not sure when the fuel filter was last replaced, if ever.  Will check it out.

______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (4/23)
 7/9/13 3:46pm
tbirdsps
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Ridgecrest, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1990 Coupe


Joined: 2/19/2013
Posts: 117

Laurie,
 
I know little about 95s.  Symptoms sound like it could be a vacuum leak of some sort.  Vacuum leaks can cause it to run lean which results in hot cylinders which could cause pinging and erratic idle.
 
Check all the hoses, throttle body and anything attached to the intake manifold for leaks.  The clean way is to use propane. NOT lots of propane but a little propane torch with the valve cracked open but not lit.  The dirty way is carb cleaner or the like.  When you hit a leak the idle will smooth out, and when you stop spraying it'll get rough again. go around all the seams where gaskets are and mounting bolts etc.  When you check hoses the smallest crack will cause a vacuum leak.
 
Since there are no codes or check engine light I'd almost bet there's a leak.  A misfire won't generally cause pinging as the misfiring cylinder would be wet with fuel and cool.
 
Good luck
Steve


______________
If it isn't broke, I haven't fixed it yet....
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (5/23)
 7/9/13 4:58pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

I had thought about a vacuum leak, but I'm wondering about a few things. 

1. It starts right up with no issue at all.
2. It's not just a rough idle - it's a rough ride in general, just moreso at idle.  And I mean, car-shaking rough, not just "lopey."  
3.  This came on very, very suddenly.  In the morning, it ran like a champ.  Not a hint of problem.  That very afternoon, I started it up and it immediately was rough, even though it started right up.  
4.  There is a "rich" smell when running the car - like too much fuel in the mix.

Would vacuum leak still be a likely possibility under all of these circumstances?  I've not dealt with one before.

Thanks.


______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (6/23)
 7/9/13 6:32pm
tbirdsps
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Ridgecrest, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1990 Coupe


Joined: 2/19/2013
Posts: 117

Oh, I think I agree I'm afraid.  I didn't realize it was running crappy in general.  I didn't read your post thoroughly.
 
I too wonder what's going on as an engine running rich usually won't ping.  Break out the shop manual I guess.  Something is going on that's not good.  You might do a sniff check of the oil to see if fuel is getting in there.  Could indicate an injector hanging open.
 
 


______________
If it isn't broke, I haven't fixed it yet....
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (7/23)
 7/9/13 6:41pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

Oh, I hope it's not injector-related, but I'll take a whiff tonight when I get home.  Hopefully, will be able to sort it out sooner rather than later.  Hate to have the car sitting and not be able to drive it.  Before this issue, the car ran like a top.

______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (8/23)
 7/9/13 10:49pm
Adams' Apple
Standard Member
Moderator
Send Private Message

Duncanville, TX - USA

Vette(s):
1985 Coupe-L98/Auto,Bright Red/Carmine. 1974 Coupe-L48/4speed, Medium Red Metallic/Black Deluxe.


Joined: 3/18/2009
Posts: 2230

A vacuum leak can certainly cause all of the symptoms...depending on where the leak actually is.
Another possibility is an EGR valve that is stuck open.
Unfortunately, the most common cause for symptoms like these is a problem with the Opti-Spark, or the ignition module. An ignition problem can rear it's ugly head at any given moment, with no notice.
Just because the Check Engine light is not on doesn't mean it has not set any codes. I would have it scanned while it is running....once you turn the key off, any soft codes will be gone.


______________

Joel Adams  
My Link

 
   
(click for Texas-sized view!)             NCRS

"Money can't buy happiness -- but somehow it's more comforting to cry in a CORVETTE than in a Kia"

Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (9/23)
 7/9/13 10:56pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

Joel, I've pulled codes from my 85 before, but without the engine running.  I used a paperclip.  I know I can do the paperclip on the 95, but how do you do codes while the engine is running?  If it is setting one while running, I'd like to see what it is to help me know whether or not I'm barking up the right tree.

Steve, took a whiff of the oil.  I felt I detected some fuel scent, but my husband doesn't think so.  Well, there you have it LOL.  


______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (10/23)
 7/9/13 10:57pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

Oh, and EGR valve looked fine upon visual inspection, so I think it's not stuck open.



______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (11/23)
 7/10/13 11:49am
davep85c4
Former Member

Send Private Message

Joined: 4/4/2009
Posts: 254

An engine that is running LEAN will detonate "ping". An engine that is misfiring (ignition; optispark) does not.  Vacuum leaks are not intermittent. The problem does not go away for periods of time like Laurie's has if caused by a vacuum leak. EGR open too far, or at light throttle (wrong time), will cause lean mixture, rough running, and detonation.

I also suspect the EGR valve. These valves have several modes of operation, but as the passages become clogged with soot during normal service, the valve's tendency to remain closed by pressure differential (the way its designed to) becomes impaired.

With the engine running, put your fingers under the body of the valve. There's a neoprene diaphragm. Push it inwards, engine should run rough or stall. The higher you lift it, the quicker and more severely the engine should react. If you can lift the diaphragm all the way up, and engine doesn't react much, the passages are clogged, and could be contributing to your rough running issue.

Laurie: You show a keen interest in understanding how your Corvettes work and function. I highly suggest you obtain the Helm's manuals for your cars. They aren't inexpensive, and the one for the 85 may be out of print (can be found on ebay), but these manuals are a treasure trove of information. Just reading a few random pages with coffee in the morning will teach you a ton about your cars.

I learned one the other day during casual reading. Try this in your 95:

Roll down the drivers window (So you CAN'T lock the keys in it).
Put the key in the ignition.
Lock doors with power door locks.
Close both doors.
Doors should unlock. The idea is that the keys can't be locked in the car, if left in the ignition.

This is pretty neat. I don't have a 95 or 96 to try it in, though.
Regards,
DaveP







|UPDATED|7/10/2013 8:49:03 AM (AZT)|/UPDATED|
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (12/23)
 7/10/13 2:37pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

Hi Dave,  we'll investigate the EGR valve.  One thing, though, is that this hasn't been an intermittent issue.  This came on severely and suddenly.  Monday morning, the car drove in its usual great, smooth manner.  That afternoon, I started it up, and it was very rough - car shaking rough, along with some pinging.  It has not done either of these things before, and the problem has remained, so we're not driving it. 

The one thing that was intermittent was the slightly high idle that went away when restarting the car.  But, the car wasn't running rough or pinging when that happened, and I don't know if the the slightly high idle was some sort of precursor to what happening Monday afternoon, or if it's completely unrelated.

I've got a set of 95 FSMs on the way, but will look into these other manuals, as well.  I have the FSM for the 85, and it's come in handy.  I am quite interested in how these cars work.  They are not simply transportation, but are very interesting machines, as well, and it seems they're quickly becoming a hobby.  I don't have the background, training or tools to do a lot of things myself, but I've been able to successfully do a few things, and I feel good about that.  Over time, I'd like to learn more and also obtain some tools to help out, besides the most basic tools.  

I will try out the door thing, too.  That's pretty cool, and I want to see it in action.


______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (13/23)
 7/10/13 2:53pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

I just spoke with my husband, who's at home with the car.  He did the test on the EGR valve, and the car got noticeably rougher and was about to stall.  He let up on the diaphragm at that point, and it went back to its current level of functioning.  So, I guess it's not that.  Too bad.  I think I could have replaced that myself.  He did notice a knock, though, that made him think a problem with one of the injectors may very well be an issue.  A stuck injector has been suggested to us.  But, we will have to have a mechanic test the injectors, since we don't have anything to do that.  He's going to have it looked at tomorrow to see about the injectors.  We already looked at the injector fuses (along with a number of other fuses) last night, and they're both fine.  

______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (14/23)
 7/12/13 2:49pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

The car is at the shop and it turned out to be the Optispark.  At just under 100,000 miles, we decided to be prudent and change the water pump at the same time as the distributor.  Thanks to everyone for all the helpful advice.   You guys are great.

______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (15/23)
 7/13/13 11:03am
Adams' Apple
Standard Member
Moderator
Send Private Message

Duncanville, TX - USA

Vette(s):
1985 Coupe-L98/Auto,Bright Red/Carmine. 1974 Coupe-L48/4speed, Medium Red Metallic/Black Deluxe.


Joined: 3/18/2009
Posts: 2230

Thumbs Up

______________

Joel Adams  
My Link

 
   
(click for Texas-sized view!)             NCRS

"Money can't buy happiness -- but somehow it's more comforting to cry in a CORVETTE than in a Kia"

Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (16/23)
 7/16/13 10:36am
tbirdsps
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Ridgecrest, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1990 Coupe


Joined: 2/19/2013
Posts: 117

Back in the old days:
 
If you think the carb is bad, replace the distributor and visa versa.
 
Opti spark- I know nothing?  But it makes perfect sense.  Too bad it's not cheap....


______________
If it isn't broke, I haven't fixed it yet....
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (17/23)
 7/16/13 6:08pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

Steve, the good old days have something to be said for them.  These modern cars have a lot more than can go wrong LOL!  

Anyway, the new Opti-spark came today, and when the mechanic went to replace it, lo and behold, there was an issue.  I wasn't sure what was up, I just knew that there was an issue from talking to my husband.  So, I called Sac City Corvettes, from where we purchased the new Opti, and they were extremely helpful.  Matt from SCC called our mechanic to find out what was up and to make sure it wasn't an error on SCC's part.  Turns out that the previous owner had replaced the Opti once before, but used an MSD brand Opti. That is fine, except the MSD brand doesn't use the stock harness.  Even though it wasn't SCC's issue, Matt helped out and delivered a harness to our mechanic, no extra charge.      

Let's hope that everything else goes well and we can get the car back tomorrow!  Keeping fingers crossed.


______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (18/23)
 7/16/13 8:54pm
CaledoniaBrian
Former Member

Send Private Message

, - Canada

Vette(s):
1988 Convertable


Joined: 11/3/2011
Posts: 150

Sounds like you are dealing with some up standing individuals here. Glad to hear good stories about repairs. Too often we only hear of the not so good experiences.
 Hope the rest of the story goes as well..... good luck, you will be back in the driver's seat in no time.
 


______________

Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (19/23)
 7/17/13 1:50pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

Thanks, Brian. The car is now ready, so we'll pick her up after work this evening.  Looking forward to having her back home, and was very happy with the reasonable rate we were charged for the repair.

______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (20/23)
 7/17/13 1:58pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

I also want to add that my FSM set arrived today, so I'll be checking that out tonight.  And, now that the 95 will be back home, I'm going to try Dave's door lock trick.

______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (21/23)
 7/17/13 9:26pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

Yay, she's home!  It's good to have all three cars home where they belong.  I haven't driven her yet, as I was driving the 85 home, but my husband said she runs great.  

Dave, I tried the anti-lock door your keys in the ignition trick and it works!  As soon as I closed the locked door, I hear the door unlock.  Cool feature.


______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (22/23)
 7/18/13 12:35pm
davep85c4
Former Member

Send Private Message

Joined: 4/4/2009
Posts: 254

laurieb said:
Dave, I tried the anti-lock door your keys in the ignition trick and it works!  As soon as I closed the locked door, I hear the door unlock.  Cool feature.

Neat. This is the first report that this feature actually "works".  I can't wait to try it during Operations at my next NCRS judging event.  I'm also curious how far back this feature goes, year model wise. I suspect 93, the first year of PKE, but maybe earlier. I don't have Helm's manuals for all the years, so I can't research it on my own. I need empirical input.

Glad you got your 95 fixed. The replacement with the May Suddenly Die opti was probably thought to be an "improvement" at the time it was installedd.  I look for MSD components during any pre-purchase inspection, and if found, consider the cost of replacement with OEM componets into the recommendation/ decision for purchase. MSD stuff is not "very good". It just "MaySuddenlyDie", as you found out.
Re: 95 running rough with some pinging (23/23)
 7/18/13 3:06pm
laurieb
Standard Member
Send Private Message

Sacramento, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1995 Coupe, Automatic, Dark Red Metallic, 1G1YY22P6S5100376 1985 Coupe, Automatic, Gold Metallic, 1G1YY0783F5114974


Joined: 4/11/2013
Posts: 109

Haha.  I'd never heard that - May Suddenly Die.  But, that's sure what happened.  It was fine in the morning, then running horribly in the afternoon.  At least I was able to limp home.  Some people end up totally stranded when those go.

I'm glad I could provide some data regarding the lock-out protection feature.  


______________
~Laurie~

1985 and 1995 coupes:
1985 and 1995 coupes
Our Sponsors help support C4VR