The starter itself shouldn't be draining the battery, unless there is a problem with the starter solenoid. For something to drain a new battery dead overnight would have to be a pretty good draw...unless the charging system isn't performing right.
Have you checked to see if the alternator is charging AT the battery? A defective alternator could kill the battery overnight, and not charge the battery properly, either.
These cars have a tendency to have electrical gremlins that will drive ya nuts. You have to first determine if there is proper voltage to run the car, and then chase the demons from there.
Wiring insulation wasn't all that good, either. Wiring tends to deteriorate quickly, and cause all sorts of problems.
I would suggest checking the charging system first, then all the connections at the starter, and then prolly go for replacing the starter if nothing turns up with the charging, or wiring.
|UPDATED|7/1/2012 8:11:59 AM (AZT)|/UPDATED|
______________
Joel Adams
My Link

(click for Texas-sized view!) NCRS
"Money can't buy happiness -- but somehow it's more comforting to cry in a CORVETTE than in a Kia"